Mount Desert Island - Isle au Haut

Cindy Lambert and Gretchen Feiss looked at the presence of Lupine, Lupinus polyphyllus, along the road side of these two islands, Mount Desert Island and Isle au Haut. Our research question was: Is there a difference in the presence of Lupine along roadsides on Mount Desert Island and Isle au Haut? Our prediction was Isle au Haut will not have Lupine because it is not accessible by road from the mainland as Mount Desert Island is.

Comments

I have to agree with Gretchen's comments about not finding Lupine on Mount Desert Island. During June, it can be found almost everywhere on Mount Desert Island. With only one square meter surveyed, it is impossible to draw a conclusion to answer our research question with confidence. A search of the data on Vital Signs for Lupine on Mt. Desert Island/Bar Harbor and Isle au Haut does not show any additional information to help draw a conclusion. Additional surveys will need to be done to answer this question with certainty.

I did a fair bit of hiking around Isle Au Haut both on roadsides and trails, and looked around the campsites by Duck Harbor. The only specimen I found even remotely resembling lupine was more likely a Delphinium; there were some obvious signs that it wasn't lupine. So I identified it as "not lupine." Isle Au Haut, being very remote, looked fairly pristine with a couple exceptions - I suspect that I might have encountered Rosa multiflora (not having that species card, I couldn't make the definite ID), and there were plenty devastated stands of spruce from the invasive staghorn beetle. But as the park service brochure rather brightly pointed out, these did make for some spacious newly opened areas for other species to populate.

From her post, it appears that Cynthia did not find lupine on the roadsides of Mt. Desert Island, either.

From these two observations, we could draw different conclusions. In the optimistic vein of said park service brochure, we could conclude that neither island has lupine. However, due to the obvious fact that neither of us did an exhaustive survey of the entire islands, that conclusion is not well-supported. While our prediction that lupine is more likely to exist on Mt. Desert than Isle Au Haut may still stand, our data neither decisively supports nor refutes it. It is entirely possible that our supposition that roads would be the vector for lupine invasion may have been faulty. Thus our findings indicate the need for further investigation that accounts for a different invasion vector. I would therefore recommend that a future search be conducted not on roadsides, but nearer to residential areas. Here's why I think that. Bearing in mind that lupine is a common garden plant (thank you for the Miss Rumphius reference, Cynthia), it would stand to reason that plantings around homes might be a likely vector for its distribution. As my survey of Isle Au Haut was limited to nothing more developed than the backcountry dirt roads, and failed to extend into the inhabited part of the island, an investigation of that area that yielded no lupines would be much more decisive evidence to support our hypothesis.

I have to return my computer to the tech department to get it reimaged tomorrow. Unless there is anything we've overlooked, I'll therefore be signing off until the end of August, when I can pick my laptop back up.

Thanks to Sarah and Alexa for a great training, and thanks to Cynthia for your collaboration!

Have a great summer!

Your investigations led you to conclude that more information was needed - exactly the way science often goes, right? Your thoughtfulness in the investigations, and your communications with one another have been a treat to watch from afar. The Multiflora rose question raised by Gretchen seems very intriguing to me, and I encourage you to document findings like these, even if this was not the goal of the outing. Again, scientific inquiry as we know, is not a straight line, and can be rather messy, and yes - require a fair amount of stupidity to find those breakthrough moments! Great job, team!