on 2009-10-27 in East Waterboro
Submitted by BurgandyCows on Fri, 2009-11-20 at 04:15 pm
ID was Questioned by a Vital Signs Expert Reviewer
This observation was Quality Checked by Alyssa W.
This observation was Peer Reviewed by
Field Notes
Time:12:46
Weather: Overcast
Purpose: Searching and finding evidence of invasive species.
In feeling:
Helen: Good feelings all around. With some bad luck. Idk.
Alyssa: I am happy for reasons I can not say. I had a happy morning today because I started a new book.
Ethan: I am happy because Mikeys not here.
We found a frog and maybe purple looestrife. We are feeling happy because of the dance yet depressed because Helen's cat died. Some people stole our flags and post and left our group a skateboard and a pink bike. Today we might have found oriental bittersweet. You can see by our sketch the leaf to the plant we might think is oriental bittersweet. Later, we found that the leaves may differ from Oriental/Asian bittersweets.
Supporting evidence
Our plant grows like a vine with a purple stem with green at the bottom since it is young. It has toothed, jagged leaves, with a long, pointed tip.
Beside our plant, we found red berries that had fallen to the ground. These berries were similar to those of Oriental Bittersweet.
There are thorns on the stem of the vine. They come in a simple 3-4 leaf compound pinnate.
Your pictures are great and the sketch is awesome, I would, however, check your data again. The leaf on the picture of celastrus orciculata, or oriental bittersweet, have less spines are found on it, but I can see how they are similar. I would check your data again, but your evidence is solid. Good job.
Submitted by team_zeezoo on Sat, 11/21/2009 - 22:31.
Your evidence and images are great! You made some really solid observations. I'd suggest, however, that you check your evidence against Oriental Bittersweet one more time. Oriental bittersweet doesn't have compound leaves, so what you are looking at is definitely something else.
Your observations were spot on. Just double check what you see against what you are looking. Your last sentence in your field note says it all - listen to your own best thinking next time! Actually, your field note does indicate you might have been a bit distracted at the time of your observation... What do you all think?
Submitted by vitalsleuth on Sun, 11/22/2009 - 12:09.
Your written evidence definitely supports your claim, but the leaves, stems, and berries you show in your photos don't match up with Oriental bittersweet. Take another look at you identification card and see what you think.
Vital Signs is a Gulf of Maine Research Institute Program. Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) 3.0 License.
Comments
Great evidence, but check data
Your pictures are great and the sketch is awesome, I would, however, check your data again. The leaf on the picture of celastrus orciculata, or oriental bittersweet, have less spines are found on it, but I can see how they are similar. I would check your data again, but your evidence is solid. Good job.
Evidence outshines conclusion
Your evidence and images are great! You made some really solid observations. I'd suggest, however, that you check your evidence against Oriental Bittersweet one more time. Oriental bittersweet doesn't have compound leaves, so what you are looking at is definitely something else.
Your observations were spot on. Just double check what you see against what you are looking. Your last sentence in your field note says it all - listen to your own best thinking next time! Actually, your field note does indicate you might have been a bit distracted at the time of your observation... What do you all think?
Similar, yet different
Your written evidence definitely supports your claim, but the leaves, stems, and berries you show in your photos don't match up with Oriental bittersweet. Take another look at you identification card and see what you think.